Wednesday, December 10, 2014

CALL Literary Reaction Journal4

 Reaction to THE NIGHTINGALE AND THE ROSE

Ⅰ,summary
The short story I choose to summarize and react is THE NIGHTINGALE AND THE ROSE.
In this story, there is  the bird looking for the red rose for the boy who wants to gave the red rose for  the girl to dance with her. 
私が反応し、要約しようと思った短い物語はナイチンゲールと薔薇です。
好きな女の子とダンスをするためだけに、赤いバラをあげたい少年のためにナイチンゲールという名の鳥が赤いバラを探す物語です。

Ⅱ,Reaction

1 character 
In this story,main character is only one.It is a Nightingale.
She is really obliging,but I think also she is self-indulgence
Because she died in last with leaving a red rose being colored by her blood.
この小説の中には重要キャラクターがたった一匹だけいます。
それがナイチンゲールです。彼女は本当に心が優しい、しかし私は彼女は身勝手だとも思う。
なぜなら、彼女は、彼女の血で彩られた赤いバラを残し死んでしまうからです。

2 Theme
I think this story's theme is how do you think this story.
How do you think about the bird devoted ?
I think this is thought good usually,but is this situation good?

3,Point 
I think this story's point is each personality.
The  boy is abject,and the bird is devoted.
The rose is horrific and apathy.
Their personal raised up tragedy.

Ⅲ,General opinion.

This story is very sad.
Why did she die.
The girl don't receive the red rose being colored by blood.
She is liar.
She fool the boy.
Due to this lie,the bird die.

6 comments:

  1. Hi!Naoko
    I think the story is sad too.Because the bird can't dance with him.
    The bird's purpose isn't red rose...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for comment.
      yes,this story is sad.
      He finally can't dance with the girl.
      Why is the bird dead for?I can't consent to.

      Delete
  2. It's wonderful story. I like sad story so I'm interested in it. To tell a lie is bad thing but I thought that lier was discribed in this poem beautifully.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for comment.
      um...I don't feel your opinion so I fell very glad.
      I try read again with your comment!!
      Thank you!!

      Delete
  3. Hi,Naoko.
    I think this story is sad because she died for her student, and the idea that red rose was made of blood is bad.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thank you for comment.
    I think so too.
    The bird is very kind,kind is good.But sometimes it becomes bad.It is difficult to distinguish them.

    ReplyDelete