Tuesday, November 11, 2014

CALL literary Reaction Journal 2

Reaction to to be or not to be.

 Ⅰ.summary
The poem I choose to summarize and react is To be or not to be -A soliloquy from William Shakespeare's 'Hamlet'.
The type of poem that tells a story.

Ⅱ.Reaction

1. character
In this poem,there are not nobody in spite of Hamlet.But there is actually  a ghost who is Hamlet's father.He is  related to this poem in spite of not writing in this poem.
Because Hamlet is influenced by him.
So,I can also think he is important character in this poem.
But there is no him.So important character is Hamlet probably.
I think he is very serious,so he is suffering from his father's ghost' word.
If he were I, I would not have heard father's word.And I would think that is hallucination.
But he can't do this.He believed that.It may be hallucination.

2.Point of view
This poem is first person.Because Hamlet asks himself "to be or not to be, that is a question".
And he repeat that he wonder to himself, he makes oneself depressed.

3.Appeal
I don't like this poem so much.
Because this poem is sad and Hamlet is very pity.
But it is interesting to read Hamlet's feeling.
Is it strange?How do you think my feeling?
Are you same or not ?
Of course, I like light poem or story.
But dark story gives us new feeling.
So I think we have to read many kind of poem!!!!

Ⅲ,General opinion
The poem gives us dark and depressed feelings about Hamlet's emotion.
These makes us many kind of feeling probably ,but they don't make unpleasant.
So let's read many kind of poem!!!!!  

7 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi,Naoko!
      I read the poem and I agree with the comment about your opinion.Let's talk about this poetry slowly this poem.

      Delete
    2. Hi Kana!!!
      Thank you for comment.
      Oh, I'm very glad to read your comment!
      Yes,let's talk!
      And did you see this poem's movie?
      It's very fun.If you have a chance to see it,please teach me your comment about it.

      Delete
  2. Hi,Naoko!
    I agree with the comment aboutgeneral opinion. The poem give me sad and dark impression! I think this poem is difficult for understanding.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi,Noriko!
    I think so too.
    This poem has many feeling.
    So it is fun!
    This poem gives us many impression, and we become to think deeply about this poem!

    ReplyDelete
  4.  Hi,I like Shakespeare!
    It is easy to understand your description.
    You agree with your opinion.
    Your description and
    Shakespeare is the best!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for comment!
      I like Shakespeare too!
      I like also Romeo and Juliet .
      I'm glad to read your comment!!Thank you!

      Delete